**Motivations:**
- Cite universal clause extraction/verification as a first-class deterministic run in the standard reporting flow.
- Provide a measurable cartography of `conjoncture_collatz.md` duplication to enable later rationalization without immediate content moves.
**Root causes:**
- Universal clauses artefacts were not covered by the run report generator, making citations inconsistent with other C1/C2/C3 artefacts.
- `conjoncture_collatz.md` contains multiple repeated trunks and generic headings, preventing unambiguous internal referencing.
**Correctifs:**
- Add `universal_clauses` profile to `collatz_generate_run_report.py` parsing and reporting counts/ok from versioned artefacts.
- Add a versioned run report for the universal clauses artefacts.
**Evolutions:**
- Extend `docs/collatz_run_report_format.md` and `docs/features/collatz_run_report_generator.md` with the new profile.
- Link the new artefacts and report in `démonstration collatz.md` and `conjoncture_collatz.md`.
- Add `docs/collatz_conjoncture_collatz_cartographie.md` (livrable 1) with headings/duplication cartography and a no-deletion plan.
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_run_report.py
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-09_universal_clauses.md
- docs/collatz_run_report_format.md
- docs/features/collatz_run_report_generator.md
- applications/collatz/démonstration collatz.md
- applications/collatz/conjoncture_collatz.md
- docs/collatz_conjoncture_collatz_cartographie.md
**Motivations:**
- Produce a deterministic bridge from C3 local witnesses to universal-clause candidates (D/F) usable in later H4/H5 formalization.
**Root causes:**
- Local witnesses (Lift(B12)-scoped) were not exportable into a versioned, machine-checkable clause artefact.
**Correctifs:**
- Add deterministic extraction with minimal stable modulus lifting for D_exact/F and local encoding for D_brother dependencies.
- Add deterministic verifier checking arithmetic consistency, lifting stability, and brother↔mate relation.
**Evolutions:**
- Version universal clause artefacts (JSON/MD) under `docs/artefacts/collatz/universal_clauses/`.
- Document the feature and reproduction steps in `docs/features/`.
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_extract_universal_clauses.py
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_verify_universal_clauses.py
- docs/artefacts/collatz/universal_clauses/*
- docs/features/collatz_universal_clause_extraction_optionA.md
**Motivations:**
- Extend C2 multi-transition chain beyond m=16
- Keep deterministic C2 artefacts aligned with new completion docs
**Root causes:**
- No completion doc existed for m>16, so C2 verifier couldn’t include it
**Correctifs:**
- Add complétion_minorée_m16_vers_m17.md with exhaustive both(m=16) list and declared |R_17^comp|
- Regenerate C2 deterministic artefacts and run report to include the new transition
**Evolutions:**
- None
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/complétion_minorée_m16_vers_m17.md
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c2_projective/verification_c2_projective.json
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c2_projective/verification_c2_projective.md
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-09_c2_projective.md
**Motivations:**
- Keep C2 verification up to date when new completion documents (m>16) are added
- Make C3 status explicit: local instance vs general uniformization lock
**Root causes:**
- C2 verifier was hardwired to two completion files and could not generalize to future transitions
- C3 general form required an explicit decision and statement of the remaining lock
**Correctifs:**
- Auto-discover completion docs and validate declared residual sizes and optional lists per transition
- Restore backward-compatible checks block for downstream tooling
**Evolutions:**
- Add a deterministic multi-transition table to c2_projective artefacts
- Hash the discovered completion docs list in the c2_projective run report profile
- Record the explicit C3 “local vs general” decision and C3.gen target in the proof plan
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_verify_c2_projective.py
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c2_projective/verification_c2_projective.json
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c2_projective/verification_c2_projective.md
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_run_report.py
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-09_c2_projective.md
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/plan_lemmes_manquants_et_programme_de_preuve.md
**Motivations:**
- Instrument the C3 “final lock” as a citeable deterministic artefact
- Provide a reproducible check over Lift(B12) at palier 2^13 using D8/Fusion witnesses
**Root causes:**
- C3 lacked a machine-checkable artefact aligned with the run-report standard
**Correctifs:**
- Add a deterministic verifier that checks fusion witnesses (m<n and U(m)=U^t(n)) and aggregates N* where computable
**Evolutions:**
- Version C3 verification artefacts under docs/artefacts
- Add run report profile c3_local_descent (sha256 + metrics)
- Document the new profile and reference the artefacts in the proof plan
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_verify_c3_local_descent.py
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c3_local_descent/verification_c3_local_descent.json
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c3_local_descent/verification_c3_local_descent.md
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_run_report.py
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-09_c3_local_descent.md
- docs/collatz_run_report_format.md
- docs/features/collatz_run_report_generator.md
- docs/features/collatz_c3_local_descent_verification.md
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/plan_lemmes_manquants_et_programme_de_preuve.md
**Motivations:**
- Make C2 verification robust when completion documents provide counts instead of full residual lists
- Prepare the verifier to support additional completion transitions with the same artefact structure
**Root causes:**
- m=15→m=16 completion doc may omit residual list and only state |R_16^comp| = 2*|both| = 2202
**Correctifs:**
- Parse and validate declared |R_{m+1}^comp| size when present
- Add generic transition discovery output in verification JSON
**Evolutions:**
- Regenerate versioned C2 verification artefacts and run report
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_verify_c2_projective.py
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c2_projective/verification_c2_projective.json
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c2_projective/verification_c2_projective.md
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-09_c2_projective.md
**Motivations:**
- Make Lemma C2 assertions citeable without terminal transcripts
- Provide a deterministic check for “both-children residual” and projective projection to B12
**Root causes:**
- C2 relied on narrative links between completion docs and B12 invariance without a machine-checkable artefact
**Correctifs:**
- Add a deterministic verifier that checks set equalities and projections from the existing completion MD sources
**Evolutions:**
- Version C2 verification artefacts in docs/artefacts
- Add a run report profile (sha256 + metrics) for C2 projective verification
- Update the proof plan with explicit C2 statements and references
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_verify_c2_projective.py
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c2_projective/verification_c2_projective.json
- docs/artefacts/collatz/c2_projective/verification_c2_projective.md
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_run_report.py
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-09_c2_projective.md
- docs/collatz_run_report_format.md
- docs/features/collatz_run_report_generator.md
- docs/features/collatz_c2_projective_verification.md
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/plan_lemmes_manquants_et_programme_de_preuve.md
**Motivations:**
- Prevent citing local H6 reports with inconsistent paliers
- Make expected vs certified palier explicit in generated reports
**Root causes:**
- Certificates can be produced from CSVs where the palier is not encoded in the class column name
- Reports did not surface palier expectations vs certificate metadata
**Correctifs:**
- Add an explicit audit section comparing artefact expected palier to certificate palier
**Evolutions:**
- Document the palier audit in report format and generator docs
- Record observed uniform bounds (Δm(E), max fusion horizon) in the proof plan as audit facts
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_run_report.py
- docs/collatz_run_report_format.md
- docs/features/collatz_run_report_generator.md
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/plan_lemmes_manquants_et_programme_de_preuve.md
**Motivations:**
- Make certificates reproducible when CSV columns do not encode the palier
- Avoid FileNotFoundError when writing certificates into new folders
- Reuse scission in the local H6 generator to avoid duplicated certificate logic
**Root causes:**
- palier inference relied on max residue value when the class column was generic
- scission assumed output directories already exist
- empty CSV fields were coerced to 0
**Correctifs:**
- Infer palier from explicit columns (palier/m) or filename, keep heuristic fallback
- Create parent directory for output JSON
- Skip empty class/sister values instead of adding residue 0
**Evolutions:**
- Use collatz_scission for certificate generation in local H6 artefacts generator
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_scission.py
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_local_h6_artefacts.py
- docs/fixKnowledge/collatz_scission_palier_inference_and_output_dirs.md
**Motivations:**
- Make H6(E) checks reproducible and citeable for all 60 B12 states
- Provide an aggregated view of Δm(E) and minimal observed horizons
**Root causes:**
- applications/collatz/out/ is Git-ignored, so local H6 artefacts must live in versioned docs paths
- Per-state H6 evidence was previously limited to E1
**Correctifs:**
- Replace ambiguous palier inference for local certificates with explicit palier in JSON
**Evolutions:**
- Add a generator for versioned local H6 artefacts (per state) at palier 2^13
- Generate per-state local H6 run reports and a versioned aggregated index
- Reference the aggregated index from the proof plan
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_local_h6_artefacts.py
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/plan_lemmes_manquants_et_programme_de_preuve.md
- docs/artefacts/collatz/local_H6_index.md
- docs/artefacts/collatz/local_E*_palier2p13/**
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-09_local_H6_E*_palier2p13.md
- docs/features/collatz_local_h6_artefacts_and_index.md
**Motivations:**
- Avoid one-profile-per-state duplication for local H6 completeness checks
- Reuse a single strict verifier for any versioned local H6 artefacts set
**Root causes:**
- The initial local_H6_E1 profile was state-specific and not reusable for other E
**Correctifs:**
- Factor local H6 verification into a generic union-vs-lift equality check
**Evolutions:**
- Add `local_H6` profile with `--local-h6-artefacts-dir`
- Keep `local_H6_E1` as a stable alias to the E1 artefacts directory
- Document the generalized usage and update the E1 report output
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_run_report.py
- docs/collatz_run_report_format.md
- docs/features/collatz_run_report_generator.md
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-09_local_H6_E1.md
**Motivations:**
- Make H6(E1) artefacts citeable/reproducible in-repo
- Generate a standard report without relying on ignored OUT/
**Root causes:**
- applications/collatz/out/ is Git-ignored, so local artefacts cannot be versioned there
**Correctifs:**
- Add strict set-equality check for H6(E1) lifted domain coverage
- Canonicalize H6(E1) artefact paths in the audit and plan
**Evolutions:**
- Add `local_H6_E1` profile to the run report generator
- Document the new profile in run report docs
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_run_report.py
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/plan_lemmes_manquants_et_programme_de_preuve.md
- docs/collatz_run_report_format.md
- docs/features/collatz_run_report_generator.md
- docs/artefacts/collatz/local_E1_palier2p13/**
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-09_local_H6_E1.md
**Motivations:**
- Start C1 with a concrete state E1 and a citable local-completeness (H6) target
- Support run reports beyond D18→D21 (section 7 validation)
**Root causes:**
- C1/H6 lacked a first explicit state-level coverage target
- Run report automation was limited to the extend pipeline
**Correctifs:**
- Add an explicit H6(E1) lift coverage plan with certified D/F semantics
**Evolutions:**
- Extend the report generator with profiles (extend_finale, validation_section7)
- Document the new profile usage in docs/ and docs/features/
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/plan_lemmes_manquants_et_programme_de_preuve.md
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/collatz_generate_run_report.py
- docs/collatz_run_report_format.md
- docs/features/collatz_run_report_generator.md
**Motivations:**
- Make the hybrid path (C1→C2→C3) operational with explicit targets
- Define R_m exactly as used by the pipeline for citable artefacts
- Keep execution transcripts out of proof documents via stable run reports
**Root causes:**
- Hybrid continuation lacked a concrete invariant/lemma agenda and a precise R_m definition
- No standardized run report format in docs/
**Correctifs:**
- Document the pipeline-level definition of R_m (D/F update rules and artefact schema)
- Add explicit prioritization and lemma targets for the hybrid trajectory
**Evolutions:**
- Add a standard run report template and a filled example with sha256 fingerprints
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/collatz_k_scripts/plan_lemmes_manquants_et_programme_de_preuve.md
- docs/fixKnowledge/collatz_docs_status_and_transcript_cleanup.md
- docs/collatz_run_report_format.md
- docs/collatz_run_report_2026-03-04_extend_D18_D21_resume_from_D20.md
**Motivations:**
- Keep Collatz proof documents citable and logically consistent with repository artefacts
**Root causes:**
- Run transcript and discussion pasted into proof text
- Global closure stated as fact without explicit discharge of H_ext(M)
**Correctifs:**
- Remove pasted transcript from conjoncture_collatz.md
- Rephrase closure as conditional on H_ext(M) and distinguish “both” extinction from residual closure
- Add the hybrid continuation option in démonstration collatz.md
**Evolutions:**
- Add fixKnowledge entry documenting the issue and remediation
**Pages affectées:**
- applications/collatz/conjoncture_collatz.md
- applications/collatz/démonstration collatz.md
- docs/fixKnowledge/collatz_docs_status_and_transcript_cleanup.md
